gurkenjoe93 wrote:
His primary position was CMF, not DMF. Don't think that 2006 to 2011 should be the era, it should be rather something like 2004 to 2008 to include his good seasons in 2004/05 and 2005/06. STA is clearly underrated here - I assume you simply took Konami value from PES 2011 - but we're speaking about a guy who usually wasn't subbed off during most of his game in 2. Bundesliga and Bundesliga because he simply possessed good stamina. HEA should be one or two points higher as well, same goes for MEN and even TMW.
As I already told you I understand and agree that you rate those Asian players with "harsher" criteria due to the weaker level of their leagues but Roda Antar doesn't belong to those guys since he was able to keep up with the level of both Bundesliga/2. Bundesliga during those years.
2004-05: 30 matches, 4 of them only for a very short time. Also, he scored once after entering in the last minutes.
2005-06: 23 matches. In this season too he scored twice after coming in as substitute. Could he have the Super Sub card or aren't those late goals enough?
On the other hand, he played over 30 full games in both 2006-07 and 2007-08 seasons. What about splitting COND in two?
I agree regarding the rest, especially STA. I believe I was too harsh with 81. A part of what you mentioned, he constantly ran from the midfield towards the goal. What about 84? Or does he deserve even more?
It's true that I use to be harsher with players who were featured in weaker leagues but I know that Roda Antar did well in a top league like Bundesliga. If we take this fact alone to count, we might even say that Roda Antar might be the best ever Lebanese player.